Team commitment
“Did we show up” is the question leadership actually needs, and the mailbox does not answer it as a feeling. It answers it as who appeared on the attack side of which rallies, at what size, and whether later joins were still full.
By hand this is a grid: every rally of a type × every roster name × full vs depleted. That is a spreadsheet people start and abandon.
Focus
The team’s rallies of one troop type — not one player, not a keep timeline.
You may get a table on the way in: who held, who fell off, full vs dust, Effectiveness and Exchange Ratio split that way. That table is the start of the argument, not the end.
Why this used to die as a daydream
Voice attendance ≠ report presence. A player can be in every rally in comms and missing from the structured side, or present as a sliver. The useful number is joins of this type, and whether those joins were still a real march.
Questions (any wording)
Presence
- Who joined our ranged (or ground / mounted / siege) rallies, and how often?
- Who is missing from this type but present on another?
- Who sent a different type than the rest of the rally?
- Who kept showing up on the rallies that actually traded well?
Full vs depleted
- Who held a full march for the whole series?
- When did each person fall off (early / mid / late)?
- After they fell off, did they still fill or only tag in?
Trade, not just show-up
- Who looks good on Exchange Ratio only because someone else was dust?
- Who still traded on Effectiveness after they were depleted?
- Whose “commitment” is headcount with no kill share?
After the table
- Open one name and stay on them (fatigue).
- Move to a sibling type (“same team, mounted”) and take a new summary.
What a good answer looks like
A table you can argue with in the room (copy button). Definitions of “full” vs “depleted” stated. No claim about click speed or “they didn’t try” — presence and march quality only.
Common miss
Expecting this family to draw the keep tear-down. Different subset. Or asking “who rallied” with no troop type, which blends four nights into one mush.